mabfan (Michael A. Burstein) (mabfan) wrote,
mabfan (Michael A. Burstein)
mabfan

Robert's Rules of Writing #12: Tell, Don't Show

[Rule quoted from Robert's Rules of Writing: 101 Unconventional Lessons Every Writer Needs to Know by Robert Masello (Writer's Digest Books, 2005). See my original post for the rules of this discussion.]

Masello's rule #12 is a reminder to the writer that telling can sometimes be the preferred mode of storytelling, as opposed to showing. He acknowledges from the outset that this rule is the opposite of the advice usually given -- show, don't tell. But he points out that we often omit certain scenes in our writing. For example, there's no need to show your heroine going through her morning routine of brushing her teeth, getting dressed, eating breakfast, etc., if all you need to do is get her ready to go to work.

Whenever I heard the advice "Show, Don't Tell" I always felt confused as to what that meant. Isn't telling the very nature of writing a story? What does "show" mean here? So I'm going to use Masello's rule as a springboard to explain how I finally came to understand this piece of advice.

For me, the difference between showing and telling is better expressed as the difference between writing a scene and narration (or narrative summary). In a scene, you're trying to create a specific picture in the mind of your reader of the events transpiring. Each sentence you write is another step, another something that is happening. In a way, it's more like writing a play or a movie script. You need to give directions to the actors showing each step of the scene -- walk this way, turn that way, slap a face, pull out a gun. There's much more of a sense of immediacy in this form of writing.

Even a simple description of the room can have this sense of immediacy in it. Don't just say that there was a sofa and a TV set in the room. Rather, say that the sofa's ripped cushions made it forlorn, and that the pictures on the TV flickered and buzzed with static. That's showing.

Telling, on the other hand, is what to do when you just want to narrate. Perhaps you need to summarize a few days in the life of a character before getting to the important stuff. Or perhaps you're making a conscious effort to create some distance for your reader. In general, though, it'll take fewer words to get through, but you'll be sacrificing specificity.

Here's two quick examples of what I mean:

***

Telling:
Once upon a time, there was a young girl named Cinderella. She lived in a large house with her evil stepmother and stepsisters. Cinderella's family forced her to spend her days cleaning the house from top to bottom, especially the fireplace, which is how she earned her name.

Showing:
Cinderella's knees ached as she scrubbed at the bottom of the fireplace with a damp cloth. She coughed from the remnants of the old smoke that got into her lungs. She put down the cloth, closed her eyes, and took a few measured breaths.

"Cinderella! Why have you stopped working?"

Cinderella turned to look out into the parlor. Her two stepsisters sat at the table, stuffing their faces with gourmet cheeses. Her stomach rumbled; she hadn't eaten for hours, and that had been nothing but bread crumbs.

"I'm just resting for a moment," she said.

"Well, don't! We need the fireplace spotless for the reception tonight."

Cinderella looked at her sister's beautiful gowns, and then at her own dress, which felt like rough burlap against her skin.

***

You get the idea.

So remember -- it's show, don't tell. Unless it's the other way around.
Tags: personal, roberts-rules, writing-advice
Subscribe
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Comments allowed for friends only

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 2 comments